ORPHAN

Review by Chris Rennirt

As I’ve said many times before, evil children scare the fuck out of me! There’s just something extra creepy about kids—having such innocent appearances—being wickedly cruel, malevolent, and, in the worst cases, even murderous. Esther (Isabelle Fuhrman), in Orphan, is more than a most evil child; she is among the most evil of humans of any age. With that, we have what is, arguably, the best movie of its kind!

As for the dreaded spoilers, they’re hard to avoid with Orphan. First, there’s the trailer, playing like a condensed version of the movie, complete with all the highlights. If that’s not enough, we have the poster as, perhaps, the biggest spoiler of all in a single image. On it, there’s a girl in pigtails, in shadow, with the darkened recesses of her eyes making her all the more menacing, even to the most trusting among us. Around the girl’s neck is a curious ribbon covering something we’re not meant to see! That, of course, makes it all the scarier. In horror films, a ribbon around a neck means something ominous–a grisly secret, hidden trauma, or decapitation. If removed, legends say the person’s head will fall off!

Esther arrives at her new home

Yes! Before you ever see Orphan, you’ll already know that something is far from normal about Esther, even if you don’t expect her head to fall off. The title alone given to a horror film is more than enough. No. I’m not saying that an orphan is necessarily an evil monster—of course not. However, logical connections are too obvious in horror films. Most will know something’s not right with Esther, long before she proves it.

Esther (now an icon of horror herself), is played by the ever-talented Isabelle Fuhrman. Child actors have the extra difficult job of acting because they’re children. Because of their age, they have less time to be trained and learn to be good actors. It’s a wonder that they manage, so often, to act as well as the most seasoned, professional adults. And yes, Isabelle Fuhrman is one serious wonder of a child actress! At the age of 12, Fuhrman nails her part as an insane adoptee (and something else I won’t mention), with all the finesse and perfection that the best adults could deliver. Her performance in the role is matched by no other I know, in any comparable film. In scenes where Esther commits her evil deeds, Fuhrman gives the character a realism that is chilling. With a face of determination and intent, cold and calculated, she makes Esther all the more a monster and all the more disturbing. We believe Fuhrman is Esther, rather than an actress portraying her. And therein lies the essence of the impact–an evil child (as we see her) acting like an evil adult. Fuhrman’s ability, as a child, to portray a character with such realism, is proof of her superior skills as an actress of any age. A scene with Esther, a nun, and a hammer comes to mind very vividly right now!

Playful chaos? If only that was all!

In a video I watched on YouTube, made by Fuhrman, she addresses a fan question related to the issue of a child portraying a murderer: “Was it weird having to pretend to kill people?” Fuhrman answers the question in exactly the way I’d expect a professional to do so: “Not really, because once I became Esther, and I removed myself from the character, and it was just Esther, I held nothing back….it just kind of came to me in the moment, as Esther.” This is exactly the type of quality possessed by the best of actors of any age; Fuhrman not only has it but articulates it like a professional.

Topping off all of the professionalism and perfection, is an added bonus of linguistics. Fuhrman delivers an authentic Russian accent, with no acting or effort detected. Very impressive, indeed! Her performance with this alone measures ten rockets on the Rocket Meter, regardless of what the movie scores!

Esther at work, creating art as well as evil

What makes Esther even more dangerous than the typical evil orphan is, among other things, her significance in the family who adopts her and the power she has over them as a result. The couple in the movie—Kate (Vera Farmiga) and John (Peter Sarsgaard)—are vulnerable, suffering emotional devastation from the stillborn death of their last child. They desperately want the adoption to work out, excusing Esther from suspicion the point of being unbelievable at times—that is until we remember their past.

For those who haven’t seen the movie, to avoid a major spoiler, I’ll only say that the ending will surprise you, maybe even shock you (more on that later). And you’re probably saying “With so much predictability already mentioned, what could be surprising? She’s an evil orphan who does evil things!” Trust me! Whatever you expect will be far short of what the film delivers.

From the look on her face, music isn’t the only thing on Esther’s mind.

Orphan is rated R for “disturbing, violent content, sexuality, and language.” However, “Is it really that disturbing, violent, and sexual?” you ask. Yes! Orphan is surprisingly all of those things—violent, disturbing, and even more sexual than you’d expect. Why? The orphan herself is eventually part of the sexual nature of the film. In being so, the film flirts with what is unacceptable. Great controversy was originally generated by critics disturbed by the movie’s sexualized depiction of a child. But, when you discover who Esther really is, it shouldn’t be unacceptable or controversial at all. And the fact that Orphan keeps its secret so well to the end is another element that makes the movie so exceptional.

As for violence, there’s plenty—again even more than you might expect–making yet another cause of initial controversy. Yes! “How dare you depict a child in such violent ways!” some people said. and the fact that violence was mostly shown rather than implied made it all the more disturbing. And,”Is there lots of blood? you ask.” Yes, a lot! When a certain victim is hit in the head with a hammer, there is little left to the imagination. As for “disturbing,” I shouldn’t need to remind you of more than this: the violence is being perpetrated by a child actor. Case closed!

No, Esther isn’t hammering nails!

Back to acting, it’s impressive that many key performances are delivered by children. There’s the amazing performance of Isabelle already mentioned, along with Jimmy Bennett as Daniel, and Aryana Engineer as Max. Max plays the hearing-impaired daughter of Kate and John, and Daniel is the somewhat jealous, preteen son. Aryana and Jimmy match Isabelle’s energy and talent, giving the film a much greater authenticity than it could otherwise have achieved. All in all, Orphan is a movie in which the performance of child actors could make or break it; but all involved easily succeeded in “making” it.

Vera Farmiga does an excellent job as Kate—the emotionally-damaged, recovering alcoholic, still haunted by the death of her last child. Her performance, which requires copious emoting, is very authentic and realistic. Without her talent, Orphan could have fallen flat, even before Isabelle Furhman arrived as Esther. Peter Sarsgaard (John), although annoying at times in his role, does an equally professional job. As John, Peter plays the part of a husband we want to scream at and yell “Wake up and listen to your wife!” However, Peter is playing John as he’s meant to be played, and again, as so many such people really are—annoying as fuck but really like that nonetheless! Kudos to Peter Sarsgaard for so well playing a part that likely annoyed him as well. Overall, the seasoned and dedicated acting of Farmiga and Sarsgaard elevate Orphan to a level it could not have achieved without them.

Kate (Vera Farmiga) losing her own sanity

And don’t get me started about the part of Dr. Browning, played by Margo Martindale. She is an excellent, veteran character actor who is always believable, regardless of her role. (I think I’d believe her if she played the part of an alien from outer space in this movie.) Martindale has the sort of believable presence you’d feel listening to your own mother say, “I love you.” As Dr. Browning, she is actually more annoying than John. “Why?” you ask. It’s probably because she’s the professional character in the movie we expect to save the day by providing clinical help for Esther—but she doesn’t. Instead, Dr. Browning is…well…I’ll let you see that for yourself too. I’ll only add that Martindale does another awesome job being believable, when we might want to believe otherwise. She also gives personality to a character who might otherwise blend into the background.

CCH Pounder is another veteran character actor who always delivers a solid performance, often playing people you can trust. She does a great job of that in Orphan, as well as I’ve seen her do it elsewhere. Here, Pounder plays the ever-convincing part of Sister Abigail—the one in charge of the orphanage where Esther initially resides. Like Margo Martindale, Pounder’s presence gives Orphan an even greater air of authenticity. Not that the movie needs it, but Pounder reinforces it. I have read that David Johnson wrote the part of Sister Abigail with CCH Pounder in mind; that is ever so obvious, as she’s perfect for the role.

Alex (Aryana Engineer) hears more than she wants to know from Esther (Isabelle Fuhrman)

I’ve heard other reviewers criticize the way that John is so unwilling to believe Kate, brushing off all of her concerns, thinking it all a part of her dysfunctional past and present. Again, I ask why viewers so often want movie characters to do what is logical, when people so often aren’t logical in life? How often have we all had someone not believe our concerns, regardless of how logical they are? Too many times to count! Based on what people consider symptoms of a bad movie, I’ve often felt like I was living a bad movie. But unfortunately, it was reality! So, for all of you who expect things to be logical, rather than the way they often are, I say wake up! Reality is often stranger than the worst fiction!

Are there problems with Orphan—plot holes, sundry ridiculous behaviors, and/or various unbelievable events? I say no. There are no moments that make me stop and wonder how the story got from here to there. There are no moments when characters do things that make me say, “You’ve got to be kidding me!” There are no moments when something happens that couldn’t be part of real-world headlines. This is something that many such movies don’t have—the element of being possible, and all the scarier because of it. Orphan stayed grounded and terrifying, as a reality, albeit bizarre and unusual, that could actually happen.

What’s Esther thinking now? I’ll never tell.

The only conceivable issue with Orphan is something that isn’t really an issue at all. Before you have all the facts about Esther, you may, with good reason, find some of what’s happening to push the limits of what a child can do. You might say, “How could a child be so savvy as to conceive of such a thing?” You might say this and think there’s a problem; but never fear. The movie’s end will come soon enough…and therein lies what explains it all!

From this point, I could include an event-by-event analysis of all the evil things Esther does (like many reviewers would do). I could also tell you why Esther is insane, providing you with her complete psychological profile…but don’t count on it. Evil things in horror movies are best left to be discovered. As for things spoiled, again, the title, the movie poster, and the fact that this is a horror film spoil enough already!

Orphan is on a short list of movies of its kind that delivers its payload, effectively and efficiently, with full force. You’ll be hard pressed to find an orphan more evil than Esther; she’s one you’ll want to see but not adopt. I highly recommend the movie, with no rockets in reserve!

Orphan stars Isabelle Fuhrman, Vera Farmiga, Peter Sarsgaard, Margo Martindale, CCH Pounder, Jimmy Bennett, Aryana Engineer, Rosemary Dunsmore, Genelle Williams, and Karel Roden.  It is directed by Jaume Collet-Serra, with cinematography by Jeff Cutter, editing by Timothy Alverson, oiginal music by John Ottman, story by Alex Mace, screenplay by David Johnson, casting by Ronnie Yeskel, and art direction by Patrick Bannister and Pierre Perrault.

Rocket Rating – 10

Chris Rennirt is a movie critic and writer in Louisville, Kentucky, as well as editor in chief at Space Jockey Reviews. He has been a judge at many film festivals, including Macabre Faire Film Festival and Crimson Screen Film Fest, and he attends horror and sci-fi conventions often. Chris’ movie reviews, articles, and interviews appear in Effective Magazine and are published regularly on Space Jockey Reviews.

Leave a Reply